Closed Cases
Case file No. 0056:09 watch4 min read

The Pizza Bomber Plot Unraveled Because of a Body in a Freezer

In August 2003, a pizza deliveryman named Brian Wells robbed a bank near Erie, Pennsylvania, with a bomb locked around his neck and nine pages of scavenger-hunt instructions in his car. He died in a parking lot before the bomb squad arrived. It took the FBI nearly four years to charge anyone, and the case broke open because a man later named as an unindicted co-conspirator called police about a body in his own freezer.

6:09

Key moments

  1. The call
  2. The notes
  3. The collar
  4. The freezer
  5. The talk
  6. The charges
  7. The trial
  8. What it left

The full case

The call

On the afternoon of August twenty-eighth, 2003, a pizza deliveryman walked into a bank near Erie, Pennsylvania, with a bomb locked around his neck. Prosecutors later said the plotters watched from across the street.

Brian Wells was forty-six and had delivered pizzas for Mama Mia's Pizza-Ria in Erie for about ten years. Shortly after half past one, a payphone call ordered two pizzas to Peach Street.

The address was not a house. It was a dead-end road leading to a television transmitting tower. What happened there in the next hour has never been fully established.

What is known is this. Around half past two, Wells walked into the PNC Bank in Summit Township, about two miles away, with a note demanding two hundred fifty thousand dollars.

The notes

The note said the bomb would go off in fifteen minutes. The teller handed over what she had: eight thousand seven hundred two dollars. Wells walked out.

In his car, police found nine pages of handwritten instructions addressed to Bomb Hostage. They laid out a scavenger hunt: drive to a series of places and collect keys that would buy time or unlock the collar.

The pages warned that he was being watched, that any contact with police meant death, and ended: act now, think later, or you will die. He also carried a homemade gun shaped like a cane.

At two thirty-eight, a witness dialed nine one one about a man with something wrapped around his neck. About fifteen minutes after leaving the bank, Wells was stopped in a parking lot, handcuffed, and sat on the ground.

The collar

Wells told the officers that men had locked the device on him and forced him to rob the bank. He said it was going to go off. The bomb squad was called at four minutes past three.

Officers cleared the area and did not try to disarm it. Traffic slowed the squad. At eighteen minutes past three the device detonated, and Brian Wells died. The squad arrived three minutes later.

The collar was a hinged metal band with four keyholes under the chin, built like a giant handcuff and driven by two kitchen timers, dressed with fake wires, a toy phone, and misleading stickers.

The freezer

For weeks the investigation went nowhere. Then, on September twentieth, a man named William Rothstein called police. There was a body, he said, in a freezer at his home.

Rothstein's house stood near the tower where Wells had gone with the pizzas. The body was James Roden, boyfriend of a woman named Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong. He had died before the robbery.

Rothstein was questioned. He wrote a note insisting his situation had nothing to do with the Wells case. In July 2004 he died of cancer, and whatever he knew went with him.

In January 2005, Diehl-Armstrong pleaded guilty but mentally ill to third-degree murder in Roden's death and got seven to twenty years in state prison. The collar bomb file stayed open.

The talk

In April 2005, from prison, she told a state trooper she had information about the Wells case. Over the following months she admitted supplying the timers and said Rothstein had masterminded the plot.

Prosecutors would later say she killed Roden because he knew the plan and could reveal it. In their account, the body in the freezer was not a separate crime, but a loose end.

Another man, Kenneth Barnes, who would later admit his part, was in jail on unrelated drug charges by late 2005. He had described the crime to his brother-in-law, who turned him in.

FBI, ATF, and Pennsylvania State Police agents travelled coast to coast interviewing witnesses. The case, the prosecutor said, was complicated by the deaths of at least two people involved.

The charges

On July eleventh, 2007, nearly four years after the robbery, federal prosecutors announced an indictment. Diehl-Armstrong, fifty-eight, and Barnes, fifty-three, were charged with bank robbery, conspiracy, and a firearms count.

The motive, prosecutors said, was money. Diehl-Armstrong wanted to pay someone to kill her father. The robbery was supposed to raise the fee.

Then came the hardest part for Wells's family. The indictment named him, with Rothstein, as an unindicted co-conspirator. Prosecutors said he had been involved at the start, in a limited role.

They said the notes were written to make him look like a hostage, so he could claim he was unwilling if caught. They also said there was evidence he tried to back out.

The prosecutor called him both a participant and a victim. His family rejected it. His sister called the prosecutor a liar. His brother said Brian did not put the collar on himself.

The trial

Barnes pleaded guilty in September 2008 and got forty-five years, later halved for his testimony. Diehl-Armstrong was found incompetent to stand trial in 2008, then competent in September 2010.

Barnes testified that the original plan used a fake bomb, meant only to frighten a teller, and that Rothstein attached a live device to the collar instead. Barnes also said the collar had been tried on Wells the day before, to make sure it fit.

Prosecutors said Wells probably realised he was in danger only minutes before the robbery, when he was forced to wear the collar with its live bomb. Diehl-Armstrong testified for two days and denied everything.

On November first, 2010, after about twelve hours of deliberation, the jury convicted her of armed bank robbery, conspiracy, and using a destructive device in a crime of violence.

On February twenty-eighth, 2011, she was sentenced to life plus thirty years. Her appeal failed in 2012, and the Supreme Court declined the case in January 2013.

What it left

The case is remembered for its strangeness. But at heart it is a story about a plot that put a timer on a man's life, and a bomb squad that could not get there in time.

It is also a story of how a case gets solved. Not with a brilliant clue, but with a freezer, a prisoner who wanted to talk, and a relative who picked up the phone.

And it left a question the courts could not close. The jury decided her guilt. What Brian Wells knew, and when, rests on what others said. He never got to answer.

Shorts from this case

Sources

Photo credits

Real photos in the video and its thumbnail:

Narration is an AI voice. Real photos are credited; other images are AI-generated illustrations.

Up next
  • Case file No. 0075:47

    The Mona Lisa Was Stolen in 1911. Nobody Noticed for 26 Hours

    In August 1911, a workman in a white smock lifted the Mona Lisa off the wall of the Louvre and walked out. Nobody noticed for twenty-six hours. The painting vanished for two years, the police arrested Picasso's best friend, and the thief was finally caught when he tried to sell it to a museum director. This is the theft that made the Mona Lisa famous.

  • Case file No. 0066:13

    A Hoax Tape Hid the Yorkshire Ripper. A Traffic Stop Caught Him

    For eighteen months the hunt for the Yorkshire Ripper chased a voice on a cassette tape. The voice belonged to a hoaxer in Sunderland. The real killer, a Bradford lorry driver, was interviewed nine times and let go, partly because he had the wrong accent. He was caught by two patrol officers checking a number plate. The hoaxer was caught twenty-six years later by the saliva on his envelope.

  • Case file No. 0046:09

    Jack the Ripper Was Never Caught. A Hoax Letter Named Him

    In 1888, five women were killed in the poorest district of London, and the police questioned more than two thousand people without finding the man. The name the world remembers, Jack the Ripper, came from a letter Scotland Yard believed was written by a journalist. This is the story of the investigation that failed, and what it changed.